Tips for Providing Constructive Code Review Feedback

Code Review Feedback

Almost every single person in the software industry must have heard about code reviews and may be familiar with it. Even then the concept of reviewing codes is misinterpreted. People in this industry generally assume that performing tests must be sufficient to meet the requirements of the verification process, yet it is mostly ignored in the software development life cycle. Therefore, they tend to turn a blind eye to the code review process. However, ignoring the code review process may rebound and have major consequences in response. Code review is a favorable quality assurance practice that assures high-quality and sustainable code and extends knowledge across team members. However, with the value and usefulness of the code review feedback, the value, and benefits that the team receives from the code review will increase and decrease. 

As the software developer or a quality assurance team member, you are not just responsible to write codes instead the main purpose is to deliver quality solutions to complex problems. Is the code you’ve written is meeting the quality standards and doing its job well? When the software encounters an error, can it be handled normally? Is the software safe and has sufficient performance? All these questions can only be answered if you’re providing constructive code review feedback to the developers, for this purpose expert code review services are required if you want to achieve the desired outcomes of your software product. 

Here in this article, we are revealing some of the great tips for providing respectful and constructive code review feedback;

Cross questioning is always a nice approach - The nicest way to cultivate a positive feedback culture is to ask questions rather than ask for change. Asking questions about code has many advantages. It acts as a dialogue and emphasizes that neither the reviewer nor the code author is always correct.

Asking questions also reduce confrontation. This means that code authors and code reviewers can jointly determine the appropriate course of action. It also makes it possible for the developers to discuss wise choices and learn from each other's perspective.

Feedback must be about the code not about the author - Although it’s the responsibility of the reviewer to pinpoint the errors in the codes written yet they must be very careful while providing feedback. They must not blame an author and never hurt their feelings because blaming the person instead of code leads to justification, rejections, and offensive behavior.

Feedback in the form of opinion - Do not make someone feel hurt. Although you should not blame the person who wrote the code, it is a better option to use I messages to show that feedback comes from you. First and foremost, this shows that the feedback is not a general statement or summary, but your observation, opinion, or point of view.

Remember not to be sarcastic - It is easy to detect from the tone of a person either in verbal or written form. So better be concerned about it when you are providing feedback to the code authors, if they may detect sarcasm in your feedback, chances are they may get offended and the whole product and organization would have to suffer then. 

Avoid using Condescending words - One needs to be cognizant about the choice of words when it comes to providing feedback. Words such as "just", "simple", "only" or "obvious" may be understated and condescending. It is best to remove these words from the feedback. Most of the time, they do not add any value.

An explanation for the change in codes - If you recommend changing the code, you should also explain the reason for the proposed change. If you are 100% sure that the code author knows the reason, you don't have to do this. Nevertheless, most of the time adding short explanations is better than assuming that the code author knows your reasons.

Adding value to your code feedback - To understand how to add value, you must consider who to provide feedback to. Is this a good friend, a new employee, or someone from another team? How much guidance and explanation do they need?

In addition, think creatively. 


If you’re playing the role of a reviewer, then its a heavy responsibility on your shoulders. Be sure to provide feedback that is respectable, constructive, and an author’s feelings are not being attacked. Make sure you are using a soft and guiding tone instead of blaming words which may result in the offensive behavior of the authors. It is of great importance because code writers are an organization’s great asset.  

Similar Articles

5 Easy Ways to Amplify Productivity & Profits Using Enterprise Portal Solutions

You are running a business; some processes are on point; other techniques can be improved. You know you want to grow, be more productive, and gain a competitive edge, but how? It is precisely where collaboration portal development can help! 

Decoding Java Microservices to Help You Do it Right the First Time

Easy to build and quick to deploy, Microservices are gaining momentum in the development world. Microservices reduce development complexity and allow you to adopt new technologies. Businesses looking to stay competitive are transforming their existing monolithic architecture to microservices for Java development.

Top 10 DevOps Tools To Make Your Life Easy & Work Effortless

DevOps offers a variety of tools and technologies to design, deploy, and test applications in a matter of minutes, with just a few clicks. You can tailor them to client needs and terminate them when not in use. They make processes quick and cost-effective for both the ops team and the development team.

Application Integration vs. Data Integration: Purpose, Pros, Cons & Everything in Between

Businesses need to plan and prepare before digitizing operations to survive and thrive in a dynamic business environment. If you want to get things right from the start, it is essential to know the basics of integration technologies. 

Drupal and Salesforce: How This Duo Benefits Businesses

There is no doubt about the fact that customer relationship management (CRM) software serves a critical purpose across organizations. It is no matter the industry they may be operating in. After all, they are essentially the connecting link between businesses

Magento vs Drupal Commerce: Which Web Development Platform is Better Suited for You?

Why we develop websites or why they continue to be pursued so ardently is a dated question, because it is pretty clear for anyone to see the role they play in the business world. But this question gains completely new importance when one speaks of eCommerce because here, websites are not merely meant to share information about the company.

Robotic Process Automation (RPA)

In my opinion, Robotic Process Automation is a level ahead approach that produces more beneficial support than test automation in different ways. Learn more in this article.

Why You Should Switch to the Cloud

A 2019 Gartner report about the revenue generated by cloud computing found that the global market for it was expected to touch roughly $250 billion in value. By 2022, Gartner predicts, the worldwide public cloud service revenue would reach a massive $331 billion market value by 2022

Issue Tracking Tools

Issue tracking is one of the most important parts of a software development lifecycle that cannot be skipped or omitted. While organizations emphasize on increasing their software testing efforts to improve quality and ensure faster releases, their dependency on tools increases too.